Best Jack-in-the-Box Toys Guide for Babies and Toddlers

Latest posts by Caroline Lambert (see all)

Have you seen the light on a baby’s face when they first see Jack spring out of his box? In fairness, some babies don’t love it and cry at the surprise. So, I wrote the best Jack-in-the-Box toys guide to help you find the surprise that makes a baby laugh instead of cry. It’s a challenge, but I’ll show you the tricks.

I’m a mom who cares about a child’s well-being and excitement with every toy while considering whether the toy is age-appropriate and encourages the right activities for developmental growth. The right types of toys or themed toys can spring a child’s imagination and joy into a new front while they learn.

However, I won’t focus much on learning like I usually do in this article. Instead, I’m intent on helping you find a Jack-in-the-Box toy that doesn’t lead to tears. I’d much rather have a child laughing and curious.

First: An Answer

Would you love to find a jack-in-the-box that won’t scare your little one’s face white? If so, then I’ve got a treat for your little kids. I’m focusing on which jack-in-the-box toys suit babies and toddlers because this age group is learning about communication and cause-and-effect, two lessons the toy will inspire.

It’s challenging to pick suitable jack-in-the-box toys for babies and toddlers. So, I’ll share tips on introducing little ones to the toy so that you don’t frighten them. There are many gorgeous jack-in-the-box toys available for babies and toddlers, and you’ll have no trouble once you know how to introduce them.

But first, here are the top picks of baby and toddler-friendly jack-in-the-box toys:

  1. Best Llama Llama Jack-in-the-Box
  2. Best Friendly Otter Jack-in-the-Box
  3. Best Curious George Jack-in-the-Box
  4. Best Winnie the Pooh Jack-in-the-Box
  5. Best Polka Dot Puppy Jack-in-the-Box
  6. Best Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box
  7. Best Jester the Clown Jack-in-the-Box
  8. Best Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box
  9. Best Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box
  10. Best Princess Ariel Jack-in-the-Box
  11. Best Baby Dino Jack-in-the-Box
  12. Best Pop & Glow Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box
  13. Best Star the Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box
  14. Best Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Jack-in-the-Box
  15. Best Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box

The Iconic Guide to Jack-in-the-Box Toys

Jack-in-the-box toys are excellent entertainment options for little kids. They come with educational benefits if a child loves them. However, know when to take them away from children and how to introduce new jack-in-the-box toys before scaring the hair off a baby’s head. Then, I’ll share how I picked the best ones.

How Classic is Jack-in-the-Box?

Jack-in-the-box is as classic and iconic as the regular ball, doll, and plush bear. The history dates back to the 1500s, when a German clockmaker designed the first jack-in-the-box toy. Claus, the clockmaker, created a wooden box with a metal frame and crank that would allow a Jack to pop up after playing a melody.

The history of the jack-in-the-box is pretty sketchy, and it explains why some children are terrified by the sudden pop-up. Folklore believes that an Englishman with a devil in a boot-inspired the first jack-in-the-box. That’s pretty scary in children’s terms. Fortunately, they don’t know the origins of the theories behind the toy.

Nonetheless, the jack-in-the-box is an iconic toy as old as the most popular toy. I had this toy when I was a child, and my daughter has her favorite jack-in-the-box, which is now stored for collectibility and nostalgia when she grows up. Nostalgia is a factor in the toy because many parents pass theirs down to their kids.

Jack-in-the-Box Toy Basics

Let’s move away from the scary history and look at today’s beautiful jack-in-the-box toys. You’ll find a jack-in-the-box with many characters, a clown being one famous Jack. Clowns are undoubtedly frightening and creepy for many small children. Babies and toddlers sometimes cry at birthday parties.

Preventing a child from crying about a jack-in-the-box toy is as simple as choosing the right one. There are a few baby and toddler-friendly jack-in-the-box versions, including:

  1. Animal characters are widely-acceptable for babies and toddlers because they love the furry creatures that don’t look like horror-movie characters. The Llama Llama Jack-in-the-Box is an ideal example.
  2. Classic storybook characters are friendlier for little kids, such as the Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box. Children relate to the characters from the storybooks, and they’ll feel more comfortable with the sudden surprise.
  3. Clown characters are a tough choice for babies and toddlers. Some clowns look friendly, while others look more like IT. The Jester Jack-in-the-Box has a familiar face with an inviting personality. A small percentage of babies and toddlers fear clowns, but these kids are terrified of them.
  4. Disney cartoon characters like the Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box are also more inviting and less frightening for little ones. Minnie Mouse is a welcome face for a sudden surprise, especially when the tune matches the cartoons.
  5. Some fantasy characters make friendly options. The Creations Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box is ideal for little girls who love unicorns and princesses. Dragon and centaur jack-in-the-box toys are cruel for little ones.
  6. Traditional plush bear characters are also welcome to babies and toddlers, including the Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box. Babies aren’t afraid of cuddly and soft plush toys that look like friendly bears.

Pay attention to the songs when you crank the jack-in-the-box toy because some songs can freak little kids out. However, songs that make them think of their favorite shows or characters are always welcome. It lets a child know what to expect.

Tips for Parents With Babies and Toddlers

I understand the nostalgia and iconic factors behind jack-in-the-box toys. However, the first rule is that you should never frighten a child with a toy. I don’t think they’ll overcome their fear after a few surprises. Instead, you’ll have a screaming baby or toddler, and they’ll only fear what they see in the box more after a few runs.

Jack-in-the-box toys are fantastic stimulation for babies and toddlers because they learn to communicate. They also learn about cause-and-effect. You have to draw the line as a parent. Determine whether your baby or toddler is afraid of jack-in-the-box toys. You have two steps to follow if your child’s fearful.

Image from: lokshop.gq

Step 1: Identify the Problem

Consider whether your child fears the character or song. Look at the toy and determine whether there are any creepy factors. Listen to the music closely. Some terrifying jack-in-the-box ideas to avoid include:

  • Scary clowns
  • Sock monkeys (yes, they look frightening to little kids)
  • Horror-based jack-in-the-box toys
  • Unfriendly versions that don’t smile
  • Unfamiliar characters
  • Animals you know your child fears (some kids are terrified of dogs)

Step 2: Correct the Issue

The first rule of step two is to remove the frightening jack-in-the-box toy. Any jack-in-the-box that makes a baby or toddler cry or scream is frightening. Then, you can replace it with a friendlier version after introducing a young child to the new character. For example, read a storybook to your child and find the song to play.

Let them grow comfortable with the characters before trying a new jack-in-the-box toy. Let them know what to expect before it jumps out of the box. I also recommend playing many peekaboo games with babies before giving them a jack-in-the-box. Try the new toy once a child feels comfortable with a character.

Important Rule: Stop trying jack-in-the-box toys if the two-step advice fails.

Best Jackinthebox Toys Guide

Essential Tip

Babies and toddlers have a world of information to learn, and playing with jack-in-the-box toys can help them get there. However, most jack-in-the-box toys have smaller parts. You should supervise playtime with the toy if a child’s under three.

How to Select the Best Jack-in-the-Box Toys

I wrote this piece to help parents find jack-in-the-box toys that won’t make their babies and toddlers scream. That means I want jack-in-the-box toys that fit babies and toddlers, including the best options from the six types safe for the age group. The characters must also appeal to them and look friendly with relatable music.

Best Jack-in-the-Box Toys Guide: Surprise!

It’s time to see why each toy is special now that I’ve shared the nitty-gritty of what makes jack-in-the-box toys scary for little ones and how you can work toward helping children enjoy the iconic toys. There’s an option from each category, welcome to babies and toddlers, and I’ll share the yays and nays of each.

Best Llama Llama Jack-in-the-Box

Llama Llama Jack-in-the-Box

Llama Llama comes from a storybook children love, and it represents a farm animal children assume is friendly. I know llamas are anything but pleasant, but the animals you see in petting zoos are often nice to children. Llamas are aggressive animals, but kids don’t know that. The animal looks like a tall sheep covered in wool.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Llama Llama
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Llama Llama jack-in-the-box comes from the Anna Dewdney’s famous bedtime storybook series and plays a familiar song
  • The llama jack-in-the-box has a friendly face that invites little ones to be its friend, and the box pictures match the storybook illustrations for kids to enjoy it more

Nay

  • I’m simply not a fan of llamas, but I can see many little ones loving the furry spitball

Best Friendly Otter Jack-in-the-Box

Friendly Otter Jack-in-the-Box

Otters are adorable animals with friendly faces, and they often appear on children’s television and in storybooks. An otter is a slippery animal in real life. Still, the otter jack-in-the-box is a furry and soft, enjoyable for tiny fingers. I love that it holds a starfish because of the song that plays when kids crank this beauty.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Jack Rabbit
  • Character: The Friendly Otter
  • Song: Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star

Yay

  • The Friendly Otter Jack-in-the-Box is a famous animal children love, and the song is peaceful, non-creepy, and inviting for little ears
  • The box looks gorgeous with simple artwork little ones will enjoy, and the otter holds a star to match the music when kids crank the box

Nay

  • The Friendly Otter doesn’t come from a specific story or show, but the animal and song are familiar enough to appear welcoming to little ones

Best Curious George Jack-in-the-Box

Best Curious George Jack-in-the-Box

Curious George makes the ideal Jack inside the box because a child becomes curious to find who hides inside. It’s a little ironic, and I love it. The jack-in-the-box toy also comes from a famous brand that makes a few favorites for babies and toddlers. They know monkeys are a child’s wonder, and the character is recognized.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Schylling
  • Character: Curious George
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Curious George Jack-in-the-Box comes from the famous books by H.A. Rey, and the song is one of the popular hymns for the toys
  • George is a simple monkey, and the artwork around the box depicts his nature, while the monkey Jack is soft and furry with a friendly face

Nay

  • I would’ve done a little more with the artwork around the box, but simple is sometimes the best with young kids

Best Winnie the Pooh Jack-in-the-Box

Winnie the Pooh Jack-in-the-Box

Winnie the Pooh is a much-loved and inviting character for kids. He comes from the Disney and storybook ranges. Christopher Robin and the animals from the woods are well-known around the world. I read the books and watched the movies, and so did my kids. It’s a story that came a long, long way.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Winnie the Pooh
  • Song: Winnie the Pooh Theme Song

Yay

  • The Winnie the Pooh Jack-in-the-Box toy comes from the Alan Milne book series, and the song is a familiar treat from the animated series and movies
  • I love the artwork around the box because it includes Winnie’s friends, such as Tigger, Donkey, and Piglet, all well-known and much-loved characters

Nay

  • I’m not crazy about the Winnie the Pooh Jack and think it needs more color and pizazz

Best Polka Dot Puppy Jack-in-the-Box

Polka Dot Puppy Jack-in-the-Box

Polka Dot Puppy isn’t a familiar story for my kids, but I found the little pup adorable as a jack-in-the-box. A bedtime story inspired it, but I love it because it’s a puppy. Children love puppies, apart from the few that fear them. Add polka dots to the puppy, and kids go wild for the weird little creature.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Schylling
  • Character: Polka Dot Puppy
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Polka Dot Puppy Jack-in-the-Box comes from the Jane Moncure bedtime storybook, and it’s a familiar song kids learn from a young age
  • The artwork around the box is phenomenal because it shows the puppy playing music, which fits into the musical cranking

Nay

  • Polka Dot Puppy should be black and white, so the Jack might not be familiar to kids who know the story

Best Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box

Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box

Peter Rabbit is a story as old as my childhood. My mother read it to me, and I’ve read it to my kids. Beatrix Potter captures the hearts and minds of little ones with her stories. Peter Rabbit is a classic. It’s also an animal that makes little children feel safe. Bunnies are a favorite for young children, making them a double winner.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Peter Rabbit
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box toy comes from the legendary Beatrix Potter books, and the song is a well-known choice
  • Children go wild for bunnies, and the artwork is ideal, especially the “once upon a time” scene on the front of the box

Nay

  • I don’t love Peter Rabbit’s plush Jack style because it doesn’t have many details, and I would’ve loved a more complex Jack for this one

Best Jester the Clown Jack-in-the-Box

Jester the Clown Jack-in-the-Box

I understand the clown predicament more than you realize. My daughter still hates clowns, and her first birthday party with a clown went South long before she got a jack-in-the-box toy. So, I knew never to buy her a clown version. However, Jester the Clown looks like a friendly guy for little ones who don’t mind them.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Schylling
  • Character: Jester the Clown
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Jester, the Clown Jack-in-the-Box toy, is a classic because many of these toys came with clown Jacks, and the song is iconic
  • Jester has a super friendly face and open arms, and there’s nothing creepy about him or the artwork around the box

Nay

  • Some kids will hate clowns, and you’ll have to get rid of Jester if your little one screams

Best Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box

Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box

Mickey Mouse is nearly as iconic as the type of toy, and pairing the two ideas is fantastic for little ones. Any child who loves Mickey would give this jack-in-the-box a try. Sure, they might hate surprises, but I think Mickey stands one of the best chances among the many characters. Mickey Mouse Clubhouse is a popular show now.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Mickey Mouse
  • Song: Mickey Mouse March

Yay

  • The Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box is one of my favorites besides Minnie Mouse, and the song is an original Disney tribute many kids know
  • The Mickey Mouse Jack and the artwork on the box are gorgeous, and the set comes with plush imaginative play toys for doctors (which also helps kids transcend their fear of doctor’s rooms)

Nay

  • Your little one will likely drive you mad with the Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box once they feel comfortable

Best Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box

Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box

Minnie Mouse deserves a spot next to Mickey Mouse, and little ones who watch Mickey Mouse Clubhouse will welcome this jack-in-the-box much sooner than most. Minnie Mouse also comes with plush toys suitable for babies over six months. She’d make an incredible jack-in-the-box friend for little girls.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Minnie Mouse
  • Song: Somewhere Over the Rainbow

Yay

  • The Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box is another favorite of mine because she’s so famous, and the song is an original Disney production many kids will love
  • The artwork around the box and the Minnie Mouse Jack is adorable, and the kids get a few safe plush toys to play with while enjoying Minnie

Nay

  • The accessory toys don’t make much sense for a baby of six months, but older babies and toddlers will love them

Best Princess Ariel Jack-in-the-Box

Princess Ariel Jack-in-the-Box

Ariel is another Disney princess children can feel safe when she pops out of the box. The Ariel Jack-in-the-Box toy is another familiar favorite, and young girls are sure to love her. I can already hear the song in my head before reading the confirmation. Of course, Under the Sea would make a lot of sense for this toy.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: The Little Mermaid’s Ariel
  • Song: Under the Sea

Yay

  • The Little Mermaid Jack-in-the-Box toy is another Disney princess most little girls know, and the song is a singalong beauty
  • I love the artwork around Ariel’s box, including her treasure hunting and the picture with Flounder on the rocks

Nay

  • I’m not mad about the Ariel Jack design because it lacks a lot of detail and might not look familiar

Best Baby Dino Jack-in-the-Box

Baby Dino Jack-in-the-Box

Dinosaurs can be scary, but the baby versions look adorable. Young kids won’t mind enjoying the sounds and sights of a baby dinosaur. The Schylling company designed the toy carefully for babies and toddlers, even using pastel colors to soothe their little hearts when the baby dino pops out like a weasel.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Schylling
  • Character: Baby Dino
  • Song: Pop Goes the Weasel

Yay

  • The Baby Dino Jack-in-the-Box toy is appealing to little ones because it’s a baby, and the song is a classic
  • I love the colors of the dino Jack, and the artwork around the box includes other baby dinosaurs to ease the hearts of little ones further

Nay

  • The character doesn’t come from a familiar show or storybook, which might cause issues

Best Pop & Glow Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box

Pop & Glow Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box

Unicorns are a little girl’s best friend, almost like dogs belong to a man. However, glowing unicorns are more magical, and the right girl will love this jack-in-the-box toy. I love this unicorn jack-in-the-box because it encourages tiny eyes to drift into lalaland. Also, the starry night effect of the song can put babies to sleep.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Schylling
  • Character: Pop & Glow Unicorn
  • Song: Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star

Yay

  • The Pop & Glow Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box is a beautiful creature little ones love, and the song can soothe children to sleep (except when it pops)
  • The artwork around the box and the Jack are phenomenal, and the glowing rainbow lights add a splash of friendly glamor to the toy

Nay

  • The popping unicorn could interrupt a sleeping child after the song finishes

Best Star the Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box

Maybe the popping unicorn dilemma is too much for you. Don’t worry because I have another friendly unicorn jack-in-the-box for the tiniest fan. I also love the name of this toy because Star becomes the star of the show. The toy also comes with the famous sleepy song that might put little ones to bed if the pop isn’t too loud.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Jack Rabbit
  • Character: Star the Unicorn
  • Song: Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star

Yay

  • The Star Unicron Jack-in-the-Box toy is a gorgeous design representing fantasy and dreamland, and the song is a classic
  • I love how the unicorn Jack looks real with glowing eyes and a punk hairstyle on her mane

Nay

  • I’m not mad about the artwork around the unicorn’s box, as it lacks detail

Best Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Jack-in-the-Box

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Jack-in-the-Box

Rudolph is a classic children’s tale of a reindeer that pulls Santa’s sleigh. I’d love to believe that toddlers with the Christmas spirit would simply welcome Rudolph, but that’s not a promise. Most children know the reindeer, and parents love telling his tale. Besides, it’s a friendly version of the Christmas-themed jack-in-the-box.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Kids Preferred
  • Character: Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
  • Song: Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Yay

  • The Rudolph, the Reindeer Jack-in-the-Box toy, represents a much-loved character, and the song is known everywhere
  • The Rudolph Jack is adorable and soft enough to squish, and the artwork around the box is beautiful

Nay

  • The Christmas-themed jack-in-the-box won’t work for little ones in other cultures

Best Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box

Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box

The Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box is beautiful because it represents traditional plush bears and a famous storybook. Let’s not forget that the bear also stars in movies now. I’m also impressed because the jack-in-the-box toy uses a different song from most, but kids can know the song if you play it.

Toy Basics

  • Brand: Yot Toy
  • Character: Paddington Bear
  • Song: London Bridge is Falling Down

Yay

  • The Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box toy is a salute to classic nursery rhymes and the book series by Michael Bond
  • Traditional plush bears are one of the most acceptable jack-in-the-box toys, and the artwork is beyond beautiful

Nay

  • Little ones often don’t know the song until nursery school, but you can play it for them

Top Q&As

Question: Should Babies Play With Jack-in-the-Box Toys?

Answer: Yes, you have to supervise their playtime because of small parts and the potential fear that leads to crying, but they should play with jack-in-the-box toys. Babies learn about communication and cause-and-effect from the iconic toys. Some babies fear the toys, while others giggle their little hearts out.

Question: How Old Are Jack-in-the-Box Toys?

Answer: Jack-in-the-box toys are as classic as balls and dolls because they come from the 1500s. Sure, they were scary back then, and folklore tells a tale of a demon hidden in a boot. However, they’re exciting and educational toys for little ones today and include numerous familiar and friendly characters.

Question: How Do Jack-in-the-Box Toys Work?

Answer: Jack-in-the-box toys have a simple mechanism that allows the crank to move the latch away from the lid while the box plays music. The Jack rests on a thick spring and launches through the top when the latch opens. There’s nothing magical about jack-in-the-box toys. They’re classic toys with manual mechanisms.

Best Jack-in-the-Box Toys Guide: Final Spring

I’m well-known as a mom who cares deeply for a child’s development, and jack-in-the-box toys offer developmental benefits. However, I focused on something more important here because frightening kids with toys won’t help them learn anything. Unfortunately, babies and toddlers can fear jack-in-the-box toys.

Fortunately, I shared a two-step tip on how to overcome their fears. Remember to stop forcing the toy on children if they still cry after completing the steps. You shouldn’t have trouble following the steps and picking a jack-in-the-box toy that suits babies and toddlers. Then, you can choose the best one for your little one.

Buy the Best Friendly Otter Jack-in-the-Box for a baby who loves animals, or get the Best Curious George Jack-in-the-Box if they know the monkey. Familiarity is everything, meaning the Best Winnie the Pooh Jack-in-the-Box and the Best Peter Rabbit Jack-in-the-Box are excellent choices for babies and toddlers.

The Best Mickey Mouse Jack-in-the-Box and the Best Minnie Mouse Jack-in-the-Box work just as well for Disney babies and toddlers. However, the Best Pop & Glow Unicorn Jack-in-the-Box is a showpiece with Funtime written. In addition, the Best Paddington Bear Jack-in-the-Box is a classic you can’t deny.

Jack-in-the-box toys offer fantastic learning opportunities for babies and toddlers, and you don’t need to frighten them. You don’t need the next Tik Tok or YouTube video to feature your crying baby. Instead, select the ideal choice, and order it while ensuring your little one familiarizes themselves with the character and song.

For more fantastic toys:

10 Best Monster Truck Toys – Avid Toy Insider

Best Garbage Truck Toys Guide – Avid Toy Insider

Best Blues Clues Toys Guide By Activity – Avid Toy Insider

Scroll to Top